Lawyers Explain Uncontested vs. Contested Divorce in Chicago

Uncontested vs. Contested Divorce in Chicago

It is understandable for divorcing spouses to endure enormous amounts of emotional and mental distress due to their intimate history and the implications of starting a new life apart from one another. However, legal and financial procedures do not have to be contentious, drawn out, and costly. With legal assistance from the right divorce attorney, you can finish your divorce and move on with your life.

For over 30 years, the Chicago-based family law firm of Nottage and Ward, LLP, has been guiding clients through the divorce process. With our help, you can make the best decisions for your family going forward.

Nottage and Ward, LLP, is listed by Martindale-Hubbell in its Bar Register of Preeminent Lawyers for achieving legal excellence.

To learn more, contact our Chicago office by calling (312) 332-2915 today.

Back to Top

Legal Requirements for Filing for Divorce in Illinois

Before initiating divorce proceedings, it is essential to understand the legal prerequisites in Illinois.

Residency Requirements for Divorce in Illinois

To file for divorce in Illinois, at least one spouse must have resided in the state for a minimum of 90 days before filing. This ensures that the Illinois courts have jurisdiction over the case. If a couple recently moved to Illinois, they must wait until they meet the residency requirement before proceeding with the divorce.

For cases involving the allocation of parental responsibilities, Illinois law requires that children must have lived in the state for at least six months before the court can make determinations for the allocation of parental responsibilities. This rule prevents conflicting rulings about the allocation of parental responsibilities across state lines and ensures that Illinois courts have authority over parental responsibilities.

Grounds for Divorce in a No-Fault State

Illinois follows a no-fault divorce system, meaning that neither spouse must prove wrongdoing. The only recognized ground for divorce that's needed is "irreconcilable differences," signifying that the marriage has broken down beyond repair.

For spouses to establish irreconcilable differences, they must demonstrate that they have lived separately for at least six months before finalizing the divorce. This separation period can be waived if both parties agree that the marriage is irretrievably broken.

Required Documentation and Paperwork

Common documents required for filing include the Petition for Dissolution of Marriage, financial affidavits, parenting agreements (if applicable), and any necessary disclosures related to assets and debts.

Spouses must provide full financial disclosure to ensure equitable property division and determine appropriate child support or maintenance payments. In cases where one party fails to disclose assets or income, additional legal action may be required to ensure transparency.

Back to Top

What Is an Uncontested Divorce?

Illinois is a no-fault divorce state, allowing spouses to end a marriage without having to prove wrongdoing by the other party. This simplifies the divorce process, making it easier for couples to avoid acrimonious disputes.

Many divorcing couples in Illinois choose to have an uncontested divorce where both parties agree to all the terms of the divorce settlement without requiring the court’s intervention. In an uncontested divorce, both parties and their attorneys work together to address and resolve issues amicably.

These issues may include:

• Property division
• Child support
• Parenting time
• Spousal maintenance
• Allocation of parental responsibilities
• Debt resolution
• Living arrangements
• Parental responsibility
• Who gets to keep pets

Back to Top

The Benefits of an Uncontested Divorce

An uncontested divorce only works when both parties are willing to sit down and iron out their differences together. Once the spouses and their lawyers have come to an agreement on a divorce settlement, they should only have to appear in court one time to have the judge go over and validate their settlement deal.

If both spouses are able to agree on the details, one spouse can fill out the necessary paperwork, and the other spouse only needs to sign it. Then the divorce papers will be filed with the court.

Benefits of an uncontested divorce include:

• Save time
• Save money
• Less stressful for children
• Increased harmony
• A judge will not control the outcome
• Avoid contentious settlement negotiations
• Avoid trial

Back to Top

How to Prepare for an Uncontested Divorce

Preparation is key to ensuring a smooth and efficient uncontested divorce process.

Gathering Financial Documents

Both spouses should compile essential financial records—including bank statements, tax returns, property deeds, loan documents, and retirement account information—to facilitate a transparent and fair division of assets. Having these documents readily available can expedite negotiations and prevent disputes over asset distribution.

Additionally, reviewing credit reports and outstanding debts helps both parties understand their financial obligations post-divorce.

Drafting a Parenting Plan (if children are involved)

A comprehensive parenting plan should outline arrangements to allocate parental responsibilities, schedules for parenting time, decision-making responsibilities, and provisions for child support to ensure both parents remain actively involved in their child's life. Effective parenting plans also address holiday schedules, transportation arrangements, and dispute-resolution methods to prevent future conflicts.

Negotiating Property Division Amicably

Couples should aim to reach mutual agreements on the division of marital assets and debts, considering factors such as income, contributions to the marriage, and future financial stability.

Creating a list of marital vs. non-marital assets can help streamline the negotiation process and ensure fairness. If disputes arise, mediation can be a useful tool to enable constructive discussions.

Back to Top

What Is a Contested Divorce?

When the two parties cannot come to an agreement and resolve all of the divorce-related issues on their own, then you will have to allow a judge to decide the terms of your divorce. In a contested divorce, both parties may be required to appear in court many times and will probably have to testify in front of a judge at some point.

There are two primary disadvantages to going through with a contested divorce. First, it’s generally more expensive and time-consuming. Second, since the judge is granted the power to resolve all issues, both parties cede control and may end up being dissatisfied with the judge’s ruling as a result.

If you are unable to come to an agreement with your spouse, or if your spouse is unwilling to negotiate in good faith, a contested divorce may be your best option. In these situations, it’s important to find a skilled and trusted attorney who will help you navigate the divorce process and safeguard your rights.

An Illinois contested divorce includes the following steps:

1. Filing divorce papers
2. Serving paper notifying your spouse
3. A case management conference (CMC) where the judge sets deadlines and court dates and makes decisions about how the trial will proceed
4. Discovery. Both parties request information from the other side
5. Negotiations between the two spouses and your attorneys
6. Divorce trial. Attorneys will present evidence, question witnesses, and argue their case in front of the judge.
7. The judge will issue the final decree.

Back to Top

When to Consider a Contested Divorce

Certain circumstances make a contested divorce necessary to protect one's rights and interests.

High-Conflict Divorces: Signs You Need Litigation

Litigation may be necessary if there is a history of domestic abuse, dishonesty about finances, or extreme disagreement over the allocation of parental responsibilities or asset division. In such cases, court intervention ensures that legal protections are in place to safeguard the interests of the affected spouse and children.

Dealing with an Uncooperative Spouse

If one spouse refuses to negotiate or compromises in bad faith, a contested divorce may be the only option to ensure a fair outcome. Courts can issue orders compelling cooperation or impose sanctions on parties who attempt to delay proceedings.

Protecting Your Rights in a Contentious Divorce

Hiring a skilled divorce attorney is crucial in contested cases to safeguard your rights and advocate for a favorable resolution. Attorneys help navigate complex legal issues, present evidence, and represent their clients' best interests in court.

Back to Top

Key Differences Between Uncontested and Contested Divorce

Divorce proceedings can vary significantly based on whether the divorce is uncontested or contested. Understanding the key differences can help you determine which path is best for your situation.

Level of Court Involvement

Uncontested divorces require minimal court involvement, typically only needing a single court appearance to finalize the agreement. Because both spouses agree on all major aspects of the divorce—such as property division, allocation of parental responsibilities, and financial arrangements—the judge simply reviews the settlement and grants approval. This streamlined approach reduces the time spent in court and minimizes legal complexities.

In contrast, contested divorces often involve multiple hearings, pre-trial conferences, and potentially a trial. Each step in the litigation process requires court filings, responses, and procedural motions, leading to an extended legal battle.

The need for judicial intervention means that both parties must wait for court availability, which can further lengthen the process. Additionally, judges may mandate mediation or evaluations before making final rulings, adding to the duration and complexity.

Costs and Legal Fees Comparison

Uncontested divorces are generally more cost-effective since they require fewer billable hours from attorneys and reduced court fees. Couples who settle their issues amicably can often avoid costly litigation and court battles.

Moreover, many attorneys offer flat-fee services for uncontested divorces, which can range between $1,500 and $3,500, depending on the complexity of the case.

Contested divorces, on the other hand, often involve significant legal expenses due to prolonged negotiations, discovery, and court appearances. Attorney fees can escalate quickly, particularly if the case requires professional witnesses, forensic accountants, or child allocation evaluators.

The cost of a contested divorce typically ranges from $5,000 to $30,000 or more, with high-conflict cases surpassing those estimates. The financial burden can be further exacerbated by court filing fees, deposition costs, and the potential need for appeals if one party is dissatisfied with the ruling.

Emotional and Psychological Impact on Families

Uncontested divorces tend to be less stressful, as both parties agree on major issues without extended conflict. This cooperative approach fosters a healthier post-divorce relationship, which can be especially beneficial when children are involved.

Because uncontested divorces prioritize negotiation and mutual agreement, they also help reduce emotional strain and allow both parties to move forward more quickly.

Contested divorces, on the other hand, can be emotionally draining, particularly when disputes over the allocation of parental responsibilities, finances, and property become contentious. The prolonged legal battle often results in heightened tension, anxiety, and animosity between spouses.

Likewise, in high-conflict cases, children may experience increased stress due to parental disagreements and lengthy disputes regarding the allocation of parental responsibilities. The adversarial nature of contested divorces can also negatively impact co-parenting relationships, making it harder for parents to collaborate on future decisions regarding their children.

Back to Top

Timeline: How Long Does Each Divorce Type Take?

Fast-Tracking an Uncontested Divorce

An uncontested divorce can often be finalized within a few months, depending on court availability and paperwork processing. The process is expedited when both parties are cooperative, have already agreed upon major terms, and promptly file all necessary documents. Additionally, some jurisdictions allow for online filing, further reducing processing time.

For both spouses to ensure a swift resolution, it is recommended that they work closely with their attorneys to draft a comprehensive settlement agreement before filing. Seeking mediation or legal guidance early on can also prevent unnecessary delays and ensure all paperwork meets court requirements.

Factors That Can Delay a Contested Divorce

Contested divorces can take significantly longer, sometimes lasting years, due to various factors. Disputes over finances, allocation of parental responsibilities, or hidden assets often require extensive negotiation, discovery, and, in some cases, specialist testimonies.

Other common causes of delays include disagreements over spousal support, business asset valuation, or forensic accounting investigations. If one party is uncooperative, refuses to respond to filings, or engages in delaying tactics, the court process can become prolonged.

Additionally, changes in legal representation during the case can result in further setbacks, as new attorneys must familiarize themselves with the case details.

The Role of Court Scheduling in Divorce Proceedings

Court scheduling plays a significant role in determining how long a divorce takes. Judges' dockets are often full, meaning that hearings and trial dates may be set months apart. This can slow down even the most straightforward contested divorce cases.

Other external factors, such as the availability of mediators, mandatory waiting periods imposed by state law, and the complexity of the case, can further influence scheduling. Some courts may also require mandatory pre-trial mediation or parenting classes, adding additional time to the process.

To mitigate delays, attorneys often try to resolve as many issues as possible outside of court before hearings. Exploring alternative dispute resolution methods, such as mediation or collaborative divorce, can help avoid the prolonged court timelines associated with litigation.

Back to Top

Attorneys Protecting Your Rights in a Chicago Divorce

The Chicago divorce attorneys at Nottage and Ward, LLP, are renowned in Illinois for providing top-tier legal assistance and representation to individuals in a wide variety of family law affairs.

To receive an honest assessment of your divorce case and your legal options, contact our office at (312) 332-2915 today.

Back to Top

Frequently Asked Questions About Divorce in Illinois

Can You Change a Contested Divorce to Uncontested?

Yes, if both parties reach an agreement during negotiations or mediation, a contested divorce can be converted to an uncontested one, expediting the process.

How Does Allocation of Parental Responsibilities Work in a Divorce?

Arrangements for the allocation of parental responsibilities are based on the best interests of the child, considering factors such as parental involvement, stability, and the child's preferences.

What Happens If One Spouse Refuses to Sign Divorce Papers?

If a spouse refuses to cooperate, the filing party may proceed with a default divorce, where the court can finalize the divorce without the other spouse's consent after proper notice and hearings.

By understanding these critical aspects of divorce, individuals can make informed decisions and seek the appropriate legal support to navigate the process smoothly.

Back to Top